Neighbor sues to short-circuit Jimmy Tate and Sergio Rok’s no-bid North Miami project

Nearby warehouse owner wants to block the future abandonment of an alley

Miami /
Jun.June 18, 2021 12:30 PM
An aerial of the proposed development site and warehouse with Sergio Rok and Jimmy Tate

An aerial of the proposed development site and warehouse with Sergio Rok and Jimmy Tate

The city of North Miami’s plan allowing developers Jimmy Tate and Sergio Rok to build a mixed-use project on two city-owned parking lots has hit a legal snag.

The owner of a warehouse next door to the proposed development and its tenant are suing North Miami and TR NM Holdings, an entity controlled by Tate and Rok, in Miami-Dade Circuit Court to stop the future abandonment of an alley that divides the properties.

The city intends on turning over a portion of the alley to TR NM Holdings so it can be included as part of the footprint for the mixed-use project.

TR NM Holdings would develop two buildings with 350 units, including 35 for workforce housing, as well as a 550-space garage with ground-floor commercial space of up to 20,000 square feet.

The North Miami City Council gave final approval in late May for a no-bid 99-year-lease with TR NM Holdings that requires the developer to pay the city $100,000 in annual base rent the first year with 2 percent increases every year after. The parking lots are located at 1810 Northeast 146th Street.

Tate and Rok join other builders that plan on redeveloping properties into mixed-use projects in North Miami.

According to the lawsuit, landlord 1820 146th LLC and shoe manufacturer Zigi Usa, both of which are owned by Segev Davidson, allege the city’s possible abandonment of the alley would block access to the warehouse’s three bays, two rear entry doors and the main parking area behind the property at 1820 Northeast 146th Street. The complaint states 1820 146th purchased the warehouse site in April for $3.2 million and that Zigi USA has plans to relocate into the warehouse from another space on the same block and expand its operations.

Attorney David Haber, who is representing TR NM Holdings, said the lawsuit is baseless.

“They are premising their lawsuit on a potential proposal for vacating an alley,” Haber said. “No one has moved to vacate the alley as of this date and we don’t know if anyone will ever move to vacate it.”

Haber said that if the city does move forward with abandoning the alley, 1820 146th and Zigi USA will be able to object to the matter at future public hearings. He called the lawsuit “premature.”

According to the lease language, the city may abandon the alley. But in a memo to city council members attached to the May 25 agenda, North Miami City Attorney Jeff Cazeau wrote that the developer is required to pay for the closing of the alley and the adjacent swale “upon successful conclusion of the abandonment process.”

Cazaeu declined to comment. In a June 1 motion to dismiss the lawsuit, North Miami makes the same assertions as Haber, arguing that the complaint is moot because the city has not taken any formal decision on abandoning the alley.

Anthony Narula, the lawyer for the plaintiffs, said the manner in which the city plans to abandon the alley is illegal and that the original developer of the warehouse turned over the alley so that it could be used for ingress and egress. In the lawsuit, 1820 146th and Zigi USA claim that the city is not the legal owner of the alley and cannot vacate it for the benefit of a private development.

“Just because the city doesn’t plan on moving forward with the abandonment of the alley in the near future doesn’t make it moot,” Narula said. “The developer met with my client and told him they intend to seize the alleyway. They put us on notice so we are seeking a ruling. They want to get the case dismissed so they can move forward with vacating the alley.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Turnberry Associates' Jackie Soffer and LeFrak's Richard LeFrak with Rendering of the Villa Laguna (Turnberry Associates, Getty Images, SoLe Mia Rentals)
LeFrak, Soffer kick off leasing at SoLé Mia rental
LeFrak, Soffer kick off leasing at SoLé Mia rental
Julie Jones (Getty)
Florida Luxurious Properties sues ex-partner Julie Jones over Elliman jump
Florida Luxurious Properties sues ex-partner Julie Jones over Elliman jump
From left: Monroe Capital’s Theodore Koenig, Steve Witkoff, HFZ's Ziel Feldman and Benny Shabtai with the Shore Club (Monroe, Witkoff, HFZ, Getty)
Judge awards $5M to Israeli mogul in HFZ lawsuit over failed Shore Club project in Miami Beach
Judge awards $5M to Israeli mogul in HFZ lawsuit over failed Shore Club project in Miami Beach
Carillon Miami Wellness Resort at 6801 Collins Avenue in Miami Beach (Google Maps, Getty)
Z Capital loses attempt to slap Miami Beach condo owners with $8M assessment
Z Capital loses attempt to slap Miami Beach condo owners with $8M assessment
Domenic Gatto and Banyan Cay Resort and Club (Linkedin, Banyan Cay, Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
Developers of troubled West Palm resort project facing $61M foreclosure
Developers of troubled West Palm resort project facing $61M foreclosure
KAR Properties' Shahab Karmely and  Suffolk Construction's  Peter Tuffo with 2000 Ocean  (Suffolk, KAR, Getty)
Suffolk sues for $16M, alleging unpaid work at Shahab Karmely’s Hallandale Beach condo project
Suffolk sues for $16M, alleging unpaid work at Shahab Karmely’s Hallandale Beach condo project
From left: Witkoff’s Steve Witkoff and Monroe Capital’s Theodore Koenig with the Shore Club
Witkoff, Monroe sued over alleged “crooked and secretive land grab” of Shore Club in South Beach
Witkoff, Monroe sued over alleged “crooked and secretive land grab” of Shore Club in South Beach
Adeena Weiss Ortiz and map view of 4865 Northwest 7th Street in Miami (WeissOrtiz Law, Google Maps)
Caroline Weiss locked in legal conflict with daughter over $21M loan tied to massive Blue Lagoon development
Caroline Weiss locked in legal conflict with daughter over $21M loan tied to massive Blue Lagoon development
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...