Trump Organization fights $5.8M Trump National Jupiter ruling

Trump's attorney claims judge's ruling misinterpreted the contract and allowed members to “game” the system

Miami /
Aug.August 08, 2017 03:30 PM

The Trump Organization is appealing a judge’s ruling earlier this year that would award $5.76 million to former members of the Trump National Golf Club Jupiter.

President Donald Trump’s development company filed an appeal with the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta this week, arguing that U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra incorrectly ordered the Trump Organization to repay members for improperly keeping their deposits, according to the Palm Beach Post. A judge’s February ruling awarded 65 plaintiffs $4.84 million plus $925,000 in interest.

Trump bought the then-Ritz-Carlton Golf Club & Spa for $5 million in 2012. The property, off of Donald Ross Road at 115 Eagle Tree Terrace in Jupiter, had been losing as much as $4.1 million per year, and Trump’s purchase came with the understanding that his company was assuming liability for $41 million in refundable deposits that former members were waiting to receive.

Resigned members were previously allowed to use club facilities while waiting for their deposits. They filed a class action suit in 2013 after being barred from entrance. The then-Republican presidential candidate penned at the time, “If you choose to remain on the resignation list, you’re out.” The refundable memberships ranged from $35,000 to $210,000.

Trump’s attorneys claim the organization didn’t breach the contract that members signed with the Ritz-Carlton, the Palm Beach Post reported.

In the appeal, attorney Bruce Rogow admitted the 65 members should not have been forced to pay as much as $20,000 in annual fees for a club they did not use. However, Ragow claims Marra’s ruling allows the members to “game” the system and alleges Marra misinterpreted the contract by redefining key words, according to the Palm Beach Post.

“Having signed the notices of resignation, they were gone. All that was left for them was to wait until their refund list numbers came up,” he wrote in the appeal. [Palm Beach Post]Amanda Rabines 


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Mayo Shattuck (top) and Brentwood Associates' Roger Goddu (Capital One Investor Relations, Brentwood Associates, Redfin)
Retired Chicago utility honcho sells renovated Bear’s Club mansion in Jupiter for $15M
Retired Chicago utility honcho sells renovated Bear’s Club mansion in Jupiter for $15M
From left: LRP Media Group's Ken Kahn and Gladstone Commercial Corporation's David Gladstone with 1395 University Boulevard
Media company buys office building near FAU’s Jupiter campus for $19M
Media company buys office building near FAU’s Jupiter campus for $19M
Hollywood Locations' Christopher Ursitti and 1400 Northwest 31st Avenue (Hollywood Locations, Google Maps)
Movie studio complex may rise on former incinerator site in Fort Lauderdale
Movie studio complex may rise on former incinerator site in Fort Lauderdale
Bainbridge's Richard Schechter and TPG's Avi Banyasz with Allure at Abacoa (Bainbridge, TPG, Allure at Abacoa)
Bainbridge and TPG team up for $161M purchase of a Jupiter apartment complex
Bainbridge and TPG team up for $161M purchase of a Jupiter apartment complex
Donald Trump, Eric Trump and Donald Trump Jr with 1125 South Ocean Boulevard (Premier Estate Properties, Getty)
Trump’s Palm Beach estate listed for rent asking $208K a month
Trump’s Palm Beach estate listed for rent asking $208K a month
Woodmont Properties chairman Donald Witmondt and ceo Eric Witmondt (Woodmont properties, Loopnet)
Woodmont beefs up Palm Beach Park of Commerce portfolio with $21M warehouse deal
Woodmont beefs up Palm Beach Park of Commerce portfolio with $21M warehouse deal
A photo illustration of prominent guests at the Witkoff wedding (via Instagram)
Nuptials Mar-a-Lago style: Donald Trump, Don Peebles, Barry Sternlicht among real estate elite at Witkoff wedding
Nuptials Mar-a-Lago style: Donald Trump, Don Peebles, Barry Sternlicht among real estate elite at Witkoff wedding
From left: Maury Tognarelli (seller), CEO of Heitman, and David Olney (buyer), CEO, Berkshire Residential Investment, in front of The Sophia at Abacoa apartment complex at 863 University Boulevard in Jupiter (Berkshire Residential Investment, Heitman, Realtor.com)
Multifamily craze carries on: Berkshire buys Jupiter apartment complex for $202.5M
Multifamily craze carries on: Berkshire buys Jupiter apartment complex for $202.5M
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...